Ratings and reviews for

Arsenic and Old Lace - FOR 2026 SUBSCRIPTIONS USE "MEMORIES" LINK

by Joseph Kesselring. Directed by Isaac Owen

Event Flyer

To buy tickets for "ARSENIC AND OLD LACE" as a subscription please go to https://www.ticketor.com/theatreonchester/sub26

Please note when booking subscriptions, select the regular price of $35 per ticket.

Your subscription discount will be deducted at the final payment stage.

Subscriptions close Monday 23rd February 2025

ARSENIC AND OLD LACE by Joseph Kesselring

By special arrangement with Broadway Licensing LLC servicing Dramatists Play Service Inc.

Directed by Isaac Owen

November 6th - November 28th

 

MEMORY from 1992:  One of the audience favourites.  The Brewster family is composed of maniacs, most of them homicidal.  They include: two spinster aunts, Abby and Martha, who have taken to murdering lonely old men by poisoning them with a glass of home-made elderberry wine laced with arsenic;  a brother, Teddy, who believes he is Theodore Roosevelt and another murderous brother, Jonathan, who has received plastic surgery performed by an alcoholic accomplice.  Nephew Mortimer Brewster, a drama critic, must deal with his crazy, murderous family and local police in Brooklyn, New York, as he debates whether to go through with his recent promise to marry the woman he loves.

 

Saturday and Sunday performances are 4pm matinees.

All other performances at 8pm

 

Artwork by Michael Arvithis

Arsenic and Old Lace - FOR 2026 SUBSCRIPTIONS USE "MEMORIES" LINK by Joseph Kesselring. Directed by Isaac Owen

Returns policy

All sales are final (No returns)

Exchange / Upgrade Policy:

Exchange / upgrade accepted within the same event (no money back) Click here to go to the event

Exchange / upgrade accepted up to 2 hours before the event.

Reviews and ratings

Summary:



4.7 / 5.0 based on 46 reviews

How did you like the event?

How did you like the event?

 Best show at Chester Street ever

Nov 22, 2026
by:Liz Nelson

How did you like the event?

 Totally professional - excellent production, acting, sets. The actors playing the parts were so well chosen, they seemed to match their roles perfectly. It was absorbing from start to finish and thoroughly enjoyable.

Nov 22, 2026
by:Estelle Shields

How did you like the event?

 Incredible cast, stage and show, a must watch

Nov 21, 2026
by: Verified consumer

How did you like the event?

 Bill Thomas

Nov 20, 2026
by:Bill Thomas

How did you like the event?

 What an entertaining romp.Promising first timers with some returning performers. Who knew murder can be so funny.

Nov 16, 2026
by:Lloyd Sullivan

How did you like the event?

 An Oldie but a Goodie This play stood the test of time in the hands of the Theatre on Chester. The actors did a terrific job, and the set designer and builders deserved a standing ovation!

Nov 16, 2026
by:Carolyn Alfonzetti

How did you like the event?

 Another excellent production in every way. I am still laughing the day after even knowing the story. I think this is the best I have seen of Arsenic and Old Lace after many years seeing different productions. The set was just magnificent. Well done to everyone concerned

Nov 15, 2026
by:Susan Macgregor

How did you like the event?

 Excellent performances from Mortimer & Abby, thoroughly enjoyed every moment.

Nov 15, 2026
by:Annmaree Fowler

How did you like the event?

 An entertaining afternoon. An over the top farce but nevertheless enjoyable. Great set.

Nov 14, 2026
by:Chris Schofield

How did you like the event?

 It's a very clever older play, with a great understated ending. The actors were excellent, with Aunt Abby the standout. Overall the performance was very enjoyable. I thought at times it moved a little more slowly than necessary; some of the pauses for effect could have been shorter with advantage.

Nov 14, 2026
by:Anthony Brammall

How did you like the event?

 Another superb production! There was great attention to detail in the set. All actors were convincing in their performances. The murderous Aunts were delightful.

Nov 14, 2026
by:Vivien Dunstan

How did you like the event?

 Great. Props were outstanding as was the energy levels of the performera.

Nov 14, 2026
by: Verified consumer

How did you like the event?

 well done!

Nov 14, 2026
by:Ruth Leckie

How did you like the event?

 Good plot but pay was too long 1hour each half would be better. Never seen so much constant shouting. Main actors simply don't know how to talk normally. I am very reluctant to visit theatre again. My top three amateur theatres I frequently attend are: 1) Genesian, 2) Elanora Players 3) Pymble Players.

Nov 14, 2026
by:George Fallon

How did you like the event?

 Really fun show, great performers and community vibe. Just go!

Nov 13, 2026
by: Verified consumer

How did you like the event?

 The play was very enjoyable with fine performances. The set design deserves a special mention.

Nov 13, 2026
by: Verified consumer

How did you like the event?

  the best performance by far. The young boy the main actor just out of this world. A very enjoyable show Looking forward to next years shows.

Nov 10, 2026
by: Verified consumer

How did you like the event?

 The play was hilarious, and the actors I think are just as good as you would get at a much larger theatre, if not better. I was laughing all the way through this play, and I am glad I subscribed.

Nov 09, 2026
by:Michael Craig

How did you like the event?

 We are long term subscribers. Another great show Sunday night. Special mention to Abby and Mortimer. Sorry about Tracey.

Nov 08, 2026
by: Verified consumer

How did you like the event?

 A very enjoyable evening

Nov 08, 2026
by:Terri Hirschhorn

How did you like the event?

 I have seen quite a number of Chester Street productions by now, but I truly came away last night convinced that "Arsenic and Old Lace" was the best of them. If you know the old Cary Grant movie, which is rollicking fun, the play brings all that to life with excellent acting, superb timing, and first-rate stagecraft. All the lead roles are outstanding, with particularly good portrayals of the two demure aunts, Abby and Martha, and of Mortimer. Must see!

Nov 08, 2026
by:Alan Harper

How did you like the event?

 Simply Marvellous - & the stand in for Teddy was amazing - just loved those eyes. Brilliant as always

Nov 08, 2026
by:Denise Corscadden

How did you like the event?

 Great old show - but still relevant and funny. Excellent acting. We had a great time.

Nov 08, 2026
by:Graham Watt

How did you like the event?

 This classic play was a delight. The actors showed great comic timing, the set was authentic to the time and it was very enjoyable entertainment.

Nov 08, 2026
by:Cathy Marson

How did you like the event?

 My group of five all agreed that this was without a doubt one of the best performances we have enjoyed as long time subscribers. This was a wonderful interpretation of an oldie but a goodie by the entire group of actors. Plenty of laughs and surprise moments for the audience.

Nov 07, 2026
by:John Marr

How did you like the event?

 Such fun! A lively and well-staged production, with a great set!

Nov 07, 2026
by:Benjamin Davis

How did you like the event?

 Best you've done.

Nov 06, 2026
by:Marcia Manning

How did you like the event?

 Excellent and a very good way to finish the season.

Nov 06, 2026
by:Joan Knorr

How did you like the event?

Nov 22, 2026
by:Marija Kaleda

How did you like the event?

Nov 21, 2026
by:Megan Willis

How did you like the event?

Nov 21, 2026
by: Verified consumer

How did you like the event?

Nov 21, 2026
by:Narelle Maxwell

How did you like the event?

Nov 21, 2026
by:Walter Moore

How did you like the event?

Nov 21, 2026
by: Verified consumer

How did you like the event?

Nov 15, 2026
by:Carole Elvin

How did you like the event?

Nov 15, 2026
by:Margot Nichols

How did you like the event?

Nov 15, 2026
by:Adarsh Gulati

How did you like the event?

Nov 15, 2026
by:Jill Steverson

How did you like the event?

Nov 14, 2026
by:Jolanta Szewczyk

How did you like the event?

Nov 14, 2026
by:Cathryn Jenkins

How did you like the event?

Nov 13, 2026
by:Robert Matheson

How did you like the event?

Nov 12, 2026
by:Joseph Furlong

How did you like the event?

Nov 12, 2026
by:Janet Forbes

How did you like the event?

Nov 10, 2026
by:Lorraine Sutton

How did you like the event?

Nov 08, 2026
by:Cate Cunningham

How did you like the event?

Nov 07, 2026
by:Kaye Carter
Reviews source: Reviews for Arsenic+and+Old+Lace+-+FOR+2026+SUBSCRIPTIONS+USE+%22MEMORIES%22+LINK

Some information shown above is collected from the web. TrustedViews cannot confirm the validity or accuracy of all third-party data.